Blog

Mary Alice Waring: A Moonambel Schoolgirl Writes to the “Weekly Times”

Among the many voices preserved in the children’s pages of the Weekly Times is that of Mary Alice Waring of Moonambel. Through her letters, stories, sewing competitions, and literary selections, we can glimpse the life of a thoughtful and talented rural schoolgirl in the Pyrenees district during the 1890s.

Mary Alice Waring was born at Moonambel in 1881, the daughter of John Robert Waring and Agnes Punton. She grew up at Middle Creek nearby, later described in local newspapers as Warrenmang, and attended the Kimberley State School. Although her life was brief, ending at the age of seventeen, her writings allow us to know far more about her than official records alone would ever reveal.

From Warrenmang parish plan retrieved from Public Record Office Victoria
The scale in the bottom left shows 100 chains; there are 80 chains to the mile
Moonambel is shown in the top right with a blue arrow; Kimerley school is marked with a red arrow; J R Waring, Mary Alice’s father, owned 3 parcels of land indicated with green arrows.

At twelve years of age Mary was in the sixth class and walking two miles to school each day. Her first letter to Uncle Ben’s Our Letter-Box column described everyday life at Middle Creek:

“My mamma killed a snake inside the house this year. We got a terrible fright. Papa has killed at least half a dozen, one of which was near our home.”

The letter also mentioned large ripe peaches and a thunderstorm. Uncle Ben commended her neat handwriting, an accomplishment greatly valued in Victorian schools.

Mary soon became a regular contributor. In 1894 she wrote of a serious accident in which her father injured his eye while fencing and feared he had lost his sight. She also revealed that the Weekly Times was a shared family enterprise: her younger sister Lizzie eagerly followed the children’s page, while Janey hoped to become one of Uncle Ben’s many “nieces.”

One of Mary Alice’s letters described a pet squirrel—probably a native possum—discovered beneath the family sewing machine when her brother Fred was two years old. The creature became thoroughly domesticated, climbing over its master and roaming the kitchen at night, before disappearing forever after an uncle attempted to carry it home in his pocket. The story remained part of family folklore and was later retold by Mary’s sister Janey in another newspaper.

Mary also displayed a keen eye for the landscape around her. In 1894 she described Middle Creek as a place of steep fern-covered hills, flowering wattles, violets along the creek banks, slate quarries, gold workings, and small waterfalls. Her description reads almost like a school composition exercise, reflecting both close observation and considerable skill in expression:

“There are plenty of wattle trees growing all along the banks of the creek, and when they are all out in blossom they look charming.”

Her education extended well beyond the classroom. Mary collected money for Aunt Connie’s cot at the Melbourne Children’s Hospital, joined the League of Kindness, and participated enthusiastically in the Weekly Times sewing competitions. In March 1895 she submitted a bed-jacket for the Children’s Hospital, and Aunt Connie later singled out her work as being only a little behind the leading entries. The half-yearly competition judges also awarded her a formal commendation among girls under sixteen from across Victoria.

Like many Victorian schoolchildren, Mary delighted in literature and moral instruction. In 1895 the paper published her selection of favourite quotations from Burns, Shakespeare, Douglas Jerrold, and Philip Henry. The same year it printed Evil Begets Evil, a fable submitted by the thirteen-year-old schoolgirl. Whether an original composition or an adaptation of a familiar moral tale, the story demonstrated her mastery of dialogue, narrative structure, and the conventions of the fable. Its concluding lesson was characteristically Victorian:

“Sly persons are frequently caught in their own nets, just as the fox was.”

Mary’s letters also illuminate the life of Kimberley State School. An inspector’s visit in 1894 produced a commendable result of ninety-one per cent. The school building itself served many purposes: Sunday school met there every week, church services were held once a fortnight, and social evenings and prize distributions brought the community together.

Her farewell letter to Aunt Connie in 1897 provides one of the most detailed descriptions of school life. The school had been decorated with wattle blossom for a recent social evening, and prizes were distributed to the children. Mary received a copy of The Maid of the Storm, while her sister Janey won Little Eyebright. Janey and five classmates recited The Charge of the Light Brigade, and Fred performed Tom Long Smith, the Doctor. The school was crowded, and the event was pronounced a great success.

The Maid of the Storm by Nellie Corwall and frontispiece. GoogleBooks.

That same letter also reveals a tragedy. Early in 1897 Mary developed what she described as a cold that left her deaf. She spent nine weeks in hospital and was taken to Melbourne to consult specialists. She visited Cole’s Book Arcade, the Zoological Gardens, the Botanical Gardens, and the Public Library, but medical treatment brought no improvement. She even tried remedies prescribed by a Chinese doctor, though without success.

Yet her response to this profound loss was marked by remarkable maturity:

“I used to imagine it would be worse to be deaf than what it really is.”

Weekly Times (Melbourne), 25 September 1897, p. 8

Our Letter Box
Deafness from Cold--Middle Park [Middle Creek], via Moonambel, Aug. 13, 1897.—Dear Aunt Connie,—It is such a long time since I wrote to you that I suppose you have almost forgotten me. I usually spend the evening in reading, but to-night I thought I would occupy the time in writing a farewell letter to you, and take the opportunity to wish all my cousins good-bye. After the 26th of next month I shall not be able to write to you any more. I shall then be sixteen years old.

I still take a great interest in the "Young Folks'" page and enjoy reading the numerous interesting letters, especially Louie Russell's. I would like to see her; I think she is a very amusing little girl.

Since I last wrote to you I have had the misfortune to become deaf. About the beginning of this year I got a cold, which ended in deafness. I was in an hospital up here for nine weeks, and then my father, seeing that I did not improve, took me to Melbourne to see another doctor. We went to one of the best doctors in Melbourne, but he said that he could not do me any good, so we did not stay many days. I went to Cole's Book Arcade, Zoological Gardens, Botanical Gardens, Library, and other places.

After we came back from Melbourne I went to a Chinese doctor, and got some pills from him to put in my ears. They made my ears very sore. I would not have any more pills like those put in my ears for anything, especially as they did not make me much better. The Chinese said, when I went to him, "No more harm; all right in a week"; but he was mistaken, for a good many weeks have passed, and I am still unable to hear. I used to imagine it would be worse to be deaf than what it really is.

A lot of my cousins have been writing about the Jubilee celebrations. We only had a picnic up here to celebrate the Jubilee, and the school children did not get any medals.

I do not think I told you we have Sunday school every Sunday now in the Kimberley State School. Church is also held once a fortnight in the same school. A social in aid of the Sunday school was held last Friday evening, and the prizes were given out. The Kimberley State School, in which the social was held, was decorated with wattle blossom. I got a nice prize called The Maid of the Storm, and my sister Janie got one called Little Eyebright. My brother Fred and sister Lizzie also got prizes.

My sister Janie and five of her school mates recited The Charge of the Light Brigade, and my brother Fred recited a poem called Tom Long Smith, the Doctor. The school was crowded, and everyone pronounced the social to be a success.

The bush is lovely now that the wattle trees are in bloom. I have got Uncle Ben's and Cousin Connie's photos framed. Please put Cousin Florrie's in, so that I can get it framed also.

Once more wishing you, Uncle Ben, Cousins Connie and Florrie, and all my other numerous cousins, good-bye, I will conclude with love to all.—I remain, ever your loving niece,W. Alice Waring.

(I am sorry to hear of your loss of hearing, Alice. We all hope your hearing will be restored.—Aunt Connie.)

In August 1898 the Kyneton District Hospital acknowledged receipt of the balance owing for the treatment of John Robert Waring’s daughter, indicating that her medical care continued long after her return home from Melbourne. Her death certificate records that she was attended during her final illness by Dr John Tremearne of Creswick, who last saw her on 20 October 1898.

Mary Alice Waring died at Middle Creek, Warrenmang, on 20 February 1899, aged seventeen years and five months. Her death certificate records the cause as tubercular disease of the brain, of two years’ duration, together with general debility lasting five months. The chronology strongly suggests that this prolonged illness was connected with the deafness she described in 1897, although contemporary newspapers made no explicit link.

Her funeral notice in the Avoca Mail occupied only a few lines:

The Friends of Mr J. Waring, of Warrenmang, are invited to follow the remains of his beloved daughter, Mary Alice Waring, to their last resting place, Moonambel cemetery.

Moonambel cemetery 202. I do not know if there is a gravestone for Mary Alice.

Without her letters, Mary Alice Waring might today be remembered by little more than a birth and a death registration. Instead, the pages of the Weekly Times preserve the voice of a bright and thoughtful girl who loved books, flowers, pets, family, and school life. Through them, her brief life is remembered more than one hundred and twenty five years later.

Wikitree: Mary Alice Waring (1881-1899)

Related Post: History of Moonambel and Kimberley Schools

History of Moonambel and Kimberley Schools

The history of education in the Avoca district reflects the changing fortunes of the goldfields and farming communities. Schools were established where there were families, and adapted—or physically moved—when circumstances changed. Few examples illustrate this better than Moonambel and Kimberley (later Tanwood).

Moonambel developed from a modest Church of England school established in 1861 into a substantial brick state school that continues to educate local children more than 160 years later. Kimberley’s school building began life as a church on the Raggerty diggings, was hauled by bullock team to Kimberley as the gold population shifted, and later moved again by traction engine to Tanwood, serving three different communities over more than a century.

From Vision and Realisation, A Centenary History of State Education in Victoria, Education Department of Victoria 1973, Vol 2: 1160 KIMBERLEY / TANWOOD (page 743)  

This building was first erected as a church on diggings known as Raggerty, in the Parish of Yehrip or Tehiree, County of Kara Kara. Built of hardwood with a pine ceiling, it consisted of one room and porch. Later it became a Common School. Two HTs [head teachers] were Ralph Gilsenan and W. Sutton. As the gold petered out in the diggings so did the pupils dwindle in numbers, and in 1876 (approx.) the building was shifted about 4 miles NE by bullock team to Kimberley, Parish of Warrenmang, County of Kara Kara, the contractor being J.J. Brown. Each of the walls was transported in one piece and re-erected. Among the teachers who taught at Kimberley were Misses Christy, Hogan, J. King; Messers J. Brown, P. Green, Heath, G. Coughlan, G. Tilly. The school remained for 39 years, and again the number of pupils grew less. In May 1915 the old building was again shifted NE about 2 miles to Tanwood, Parish of Warrenmang, County of Kara Kara, this time by a traction engine and jinker, owned and operated by George Walkly. The contractors for the re-erection of the school were Charles Astbury and W. Argall. The school remained on this site for 52 years and was then sold by the Department. When dismantled in May 1966 most of the timber was said to be in good condition.
The site at Tanwood is now controlled by the Moonambell School for the purpose of a School Endowment Plantation. Timber to the value of $240 was sold during clearing operations in 1966. Four hundred pinus radiata were planted in August 1968, and when fully planted the 31 acre site will accommodate approximately 2000 trees.

Tanwood Avenue of Honour

In 1918, Tanwood school students helped to plant Monterey Cypress (Cupressus macrocarpa) trees, extending about 300m along both sides of the Stawell-Avoca Road, to establish the original Tanwood Avenue of Honour, commemorating the service and sacrifice of local WW1 soldiers. The avenue has since been replaced with Red Flowering gums (Corymbia “Wildfire”).

The soldiers honoured included: World War 1: Robert Douglas Anderson Service No: 5612, William Charles Castleman Service No: 61256, Anthony Cudmore Service No: 478, Robert Luscombe Service No: 3263. World War 2: Arthur Percy Williams Service No: VX135327, Daniel Gethen Williams Service No: V240727, Gladwyss Evelyn Williams Service No: V502362, Kenneth James Williams Service No: V240728

From Vision and Realisation, A Centenary History of State Education in Victoria, Education Department of Victoria 1973, Vol 2: 439 MOONAMBEL (page 656)  

The Church of England established this school on 14th of January 1861 with Thomas Granger as HT [head teacher]. The a.a. [average attendance] of 439 Moonambel was 63 in 1862. Under the Department a schoolhouse was built in 1875, on a site gazetted on 25th of September 1874, to replace the former leased building. No. 439 closed on 30th of November 1875 and Thomas Granger opened the new school, 1683 Moonambel, on 1st of December 1875.

From Vision and Realisation, A Centenary History of State Education in Victoria, Education Department of Victoria 1973, Vol 2: 1683 MOONAMBEL (page 786)  

In October 1874 the Department called tenders for a school to be built at Moonambel. A wooden building was requested by the Mining Department, which had reserved the right to mine on the selected site. Assisted by DI Colin Campbell the Board of Advice obtained revoca-tion of the right to mine and the Department agreed to construct a brick building on the site. This is now known as Humfray St which runs parallel to the Avoca-Landsborough Rd; the school is directly behind the former post office in the main street. By October 1875 the new brick school was completed and opened on 1st December under HT Thomas Granger, who was in charge to 1882. There was an enrolment of 133 and an a.a. [average attendance] of seventy-one in 1875. This school replaced an earlier school No. 439 Moonambel - of Church of England origin dating back to 1861. No. 439, a State leased school, was struck off the roll on 30th of November 1875. Thomas Granger was HT of this school from 11th of February 1871 to 30th of November 1875. It had accommodation for 100 pupils, and a four room, teacher's residence provided. At present SS1683 has a total of thirty pupils, which requires a HM and an assistant. The active Mothers' Club and Committee have worked very hard over a period of years to equip the school very well. An endowment pine plantation, situated on the site of the old Tanwood School 1160, was planted on 22nd of August 1968.

Images from History, Moonambel Primary School website

On 24 May 1914, Empire Day, the pupils of Kimberly State School marched to Moonambel under the leadership of their teacher, Mr Tilley, where they were welcomed by Mr Forbes and the Moonambel school. The two schools shared festivities, speeches, games, and lunch.

Avoca Free Press and Farmers’ and Miners’ Journal, Wednesday 27 May 1914, page 2

MOONAMBEL.

Empire Day was fittingly celebrated at the Moonambel State school. The scholars at the Kimberly school were invited, and, under the direction of their head teacher (Mr Tilley) they marched in procession through the main street at Moonambel to the school grounds. The children carried flags, and seemed to revel in the festivities. The visitors were warmly welcomed by Mr Forbes, the master of the Moonambel school. At 12.30 o'clock luncheon was provided, and done full justice to.

During the afternoon the children saluted the flag, sang patriotic songs, and went through a number of physical exercises. Games and races were indulged in, and the successful competitors were presented with prizes. At four o'clock the parents and children sat down to tea, a bountiful repast being provided.

Mr Forbes, in a few well chosen remarks, thanked Mr Tilley, the parents and children of Kimberly for attending the function. Mr J. Fitzgerald, J.P., also made a neat speech, and Mr Tilley, in responding, expressed the hope that they would all meet again on some future occasion. As the Kimberly children took their departure, the Moonambel scholars gave three hearty cheers, which were duly acknowledged. The Kimberly juveniles were complimented on the excellent manner in which they carried out their exercises, and Mr Tilley deserved great credit for training them to such a degree of perfection.

The new flag at the Kimberly State school was unfurled on Empire Day for the first time in honor of the occasion.

In 1922, the Gippsland Times described the rural school as one of the Victorian Education Department’s greatest achievements. The article emphasised the close relationship between country schools and the industries that sustained their communities. Moonambel earned a special mention: its pupils learned the principles of eucalyptus-oil production through a miniature still set up by their teacher, linking education directly to the forests and livelihoods of the district.

Gippsland Times (Vic.), Thursday 26 October 1922, page 3

The Rural School

If the question were asked, What result of its education effort during the past fifty years represents the most distinctive achievement of the Victorian Education Department? the answer would spring to many lips would be the significant part that the rural school has come to play in the life of the community. Wherever a few families have settled in reasonable proximity to one another, be it in the Gippsland hills, or in the new wheatlands of the Western district, or in the still newer soldiers' settlements in the Mallee, there will be a school to be found among them! No country in the world has done more to provide efficient one-teacher schools for its outback population than Australia, and the Australian teacher has worked out a method of organisation and of teaching for such schools that is unique and effective.

In Victoria, where there is a sufficient number of children of school age, and where a suitable room is offered, a teacher is provided and a school opened. Where the average attendance is in the region of twenty scholars, a school is built. It is now quite common to find in remote districts school buildings of the latest pattern, well lighted, well ventilated, and equipped with dual desks, cloak rooms, hylo-plate blackboards, lunch cupboards, &c. These new or remodelled schoolrooms have quite replaced the old makeshifts—

“Battered, queer-old buildings that belong to other years,
With a dog-log fence around them and their hats about their ears.”

The needs of the most sparsely-settled districts are met either by correspondence tuition, or by subsidised schools in connection with which the department grants a subsidy of £5 per pupil in average attendance. The establishment of these subsidised schools enables school facilities to be provided for a small number of children much more freely than formerly. On 31st December, 1919, there were 2,235 elementary schools in operation in Victoria. No fewer than 970 of these had an enrolment of fewer than 20 pupils.

Once established, the rural school is not satisfied to be a mere “knowledge shop.” Instruction it does impart, but it does very much more. It ministers in the most vital ways to the well-being of the community, and its influences for good reach out in many and often unsuspected directions. More and more the school house is becoming the centre of community interest. No function brings together a larger gathering than those held at the school. This is in marked contrast to conditions thirty years ago, when the school was the “State School”—the concern of a far-off department and of State officials. To-day, it is “Our School,” and we all have duties and responsibilities towards it.

Thus the rural school affords one of the most readily usable channels for community service. Practically every family is represented in it, and the resultant benefits of such service are abundantly manifest. Hence we find school committees and parents keeping in closest touch with all the school activities, attending school functions in force, organising working bees to clear and plant the grounds and make the garden a fragrant mass of bloom, forming themselves into committees to develop plans for school decoration, and taking the keenest interest in the school sports. (In one district this year, an enthusiast on the school committee organised a football team of “has-beens” from among parents and others in order to give a final practice game to the school team competing for the district premiership). And what an excellent record in school improvement our teachers and school committees have made. Well-fenced and well-planted grounds, play pavilions, swimming baths, tennis courts, and agricultural plots are to be found around our schools to-day, while inside are the choice pictures, the school library, the piano and other aids to fine work.

The department’s attitude in regard to the subjects of instruction for rural schools in Victoria is worthy of note. In many countries, the course of study in elementary schools is differentiated for rural schools; in the latter, much lower standards than in town schools are accepted. In some cases, the rural schools are termed ungraded, to signify that the regular development of the subjects from grade to grade is not attempted. The Victorian Education Department has always insisted that the standard of education shall be as high in the rural school as in the city school. It was a sure instinct that prompted our early administrators to emphasise the necessity for sound education in the pioneer settlements. And the wonderful thing is, not only that this equality of standard is maintained, but that boys and girls taught in rural schools often show to advantage in scholarship competitions, and in their later progress in high schools and technical schools. It is interesting to record that every one of the leading administrative and professional officers of the Education Department received his early education in a small country school.

Then, in order to meet rural needs more fully, certain modifications in the course of study for rural schools has been made. To reduce the number of divisions to be taught at any one time teachers are permitted to group certain grades for simultaneous instruction, and portions of the prescriptions in history and geography are taken in alternate years. Further differentiation to meet special needs is provided for in nature-study, agriculture, gardening, and occupations. Wherever practicable, these are closely related to local industries. For example, in a potato growing district like Kyneton, the school activities in all these subjects centre around potato culture.

Pupils grow potatoes under varying conditions of tilth, manuring, and moisture; they compare yields from different varieties; they are kept in touch with the results of research elsewhere; and, sometimes, under an enthusiastic teacher, they even evolve new varieties of their own. In the rural school at Moonambel, surrounded by a State forest, the teacher has set up a miniature still, by means of which every process in the distillation of eucalyptus oil is explained. The needs of a fruit growing district are catered for by lessons and practice in budding, grafting, pruning, spraying, and other orchard operations. Many of the schools in Northern Victoria have their own miniature vineyards and orangeries. In dairying districts new grasses are tried out in the school plots, and the principles of milk testing are taught as part of the course in science. So, too, in wheat-growing areas, practical tests are made of the resistant powers of various wheats to rust and drought, and their suitability to local conditions is investigated.

This strong appeal to local interests accounts for much of the success attained by Victorian rural schools. Another most important factor has been the high professional and cultural standing of the teachers. In Victoria, the system of promotion and transfer practically compels young teachers, fresh from training and eager to try out the new ideas they have gained, to serve for a period in the country districts. Thus the man (or woman) in charge of a rural school is often a trained teacher with good academic qualifications, fired with enthusiasm for new methods, and fully seized of the fact that, to win his spurs, and qualify for promotion, he must make good both within and without the school. In some of the other Australian States, such young teachers with the higher training are at once appointed to positions in city schools, and thus the rural schools tend, more and more, to fall into the hands of teachers with lower qualifications.

It is of interest to record that the late Professor Green, of Sheffield University—a man with a wide knowledge of educational systems—said, after an inspection of a number of Victorian country schools:—“While you have done well in many fields of educational effort, there is one thing in which you have done supremely well, and that is in the development of your rural schools.”

The heritage of Kimberley and Moonambel schools remains visible in the landscape and the community, from the Tanwood Avenue of Honour planted by local students to the continuing operation of Moonambel Primary School.

Successful Evening at Avoca’s School Prize Event

In February 1876, the Shire Hall at Avoca was filled to overflowing for one of the district’s most anticipated educational events—the annual State Schools Prize Distribution. Children, parents, teachers, and community members travelled from Avoca, Bung Bong, Amphitheatre, Homebush, Percydale, Lamplough, Mountain Hut, Lillicur, and Avoca Lead to celebrate the achievements of local scholars. The evening combined prize-giving with music, recitations, and lively spelling-bee competitions. The following report from the Avoca Mail provides a vivid account of the festivities and preserves the names of many of the district’s most successful students.

Avoca Mail, Tuesday 22 February 1876, page 2

THE STATE SCHOOLS PRIZE DISTRIBUTION AT AVOCA.

This event, which had excited a good deal of interest in the district, took place on Friday evening last at the Shire Hall, and as we ventured to predict, was productive of unmitigated enjoyment as well as being eminently successful in all respects, as everyone present in the crowded audience can testify.

The Hall was well arranged and beautified by large bouquets of roses kindly sent by Mr W. H. Ford, from his well known garden at No. 1 Creek, a vase of white roses being very chaste. The prizes very appropriately took the shape of books, to which the winner of them may refer in after years with pride and gratification; and a very handsome collection they were, arranged in a row on a crimson covered shelf above the heads of those who occupied the platform; the quality of the works, too, being of the best, and shewing the good taste and judgment of the gentlemen who kindly selected them—the Hon. Robert Ramsay, Minister of Public Instruction, Mr B. G. Davies, M.L.A., chairman of committees, and Mr H. Hall, the painstaking and indefatigable correspondent.

The parents and friends of the children from Avoca, Bung Bong, Amphitheatre, Homebush, Percydale, and Lamplough, mustered in strong numbers, and the attendance of the inhabitants of Avoca was large, and, although a charge was made for admission, the hall was literally crammed full, ladies as usual largely predominating.

Mr Bolam, Inspector of Schools, presided, and carried out the varied proceedings of the evening, which occupied until close upon midnight, with politeness to the audience and kind consideration for the many children who presented themselves; some to take their well earned prizes, some to sing and recite, some to engage in the spelling-bee competitions, and all to be apparently satisfied and happy.

The Rev. D. O'Donnell gave out the words for the spellers. The musical part was under the experienced direction of Professor Cranz, and the great pains and trouble he has been at must have been rewarded by the capital singing, of the part songs especially, by his numerous pleasant looking young pupils.

The proceedings commenced by an opening overture for two pianofortes, Miss Mathers and Mr Armstrong playing on one, Miss Hall and Mr Cranz on the other. The overture was well and spiritedly played.

The chairman, Mr Bolam, remarked that those present would agree with him that it was not a proper opportunity for speech-making, for rather would the music and recitations be heard. The spread of education, he would say, however, had been very great of late years in the Home countries and here. Immense advantages had arisen and been afforded to schools and school children, and he had a firm conviction that the benefits of meetings such as the present were very great indeed. It was a good sign to see so many assembled from the different schools of the neighbourhood, shewing, as it did, good desires for the future. The prizes were well worth the winning, and every copy of the works displayed had been carefully selected by the Hon. the Minister of Education, and Mr B. G. Davies, who had kindly accompanied Mr Hall for the purpose. He hoped their value would be fully appreciated. He had no doubt of the great benefits to be derived from competitive examinations. A nervous child might occasionally fail; but as a rule the most carefully taught invariably gave the best results.—(Cheers.)

A number of very small elocutionists and singers were then ranged by Miss Bowen on the platform, and gave a song, "Watching for Pa," a recitation "The Neat Little Clock," with quaint and appropriate action, followed by a chorus-song to the old air of "Villikins and his Dinah." Master George Chambers then recited with distinct correctness "Giving a Child Away!" To this succeeded a chorus by the Avoca scholars which had been arranged by Mr Cranz, the words by Mr Cooke, and very well rendered it was.

A bevy of Percydale scholars then sang very cleverly and with true intonation, "The Milk Pail," without accompaniment, conducted by Mr Burston, the Head teacher of this school. A good feature of this performance was the distinctness of utterance of the words.

Two small mites of children, the son and daughter of Mr and Mrs Robarts of Bung Bong, then came forward and sang a duet without accompaniment, their very young voices blending most harmoniously. This was most attentively listened to, if only as a surprise, and much applauded.

The recitation by Master Loo Ching, "The March of Intellect," succeeded.

The Spelling Bee for the 3rd class was then entered upon, Mr Bolam explaining that the words would be taken from the books for the class immediately below those competing. These Spelling classes afforded real amusement during the evening, the competitions being keen and close and exciting towards the termination of each.

The prizes fell—first to Emily Louisa Summers, Homebush school; second, Maria Robarts, Bung Bong school; and third, George Macadam, Avoca school.

The Como Quadrilles for two pianos, eight hands, was capitally played by Miss Mather and Miss Smith, and Miss A. Mather and Miss Holland.

The announcement of a ballad by Miss Hammond was warmly greeted, when this young lady sang with her usual good taste and musical precision, the ballad "The Wish," and in reply to a loud encore "The Garden Gate."

Chorus by Avoca scholars, "The Happy Day," accompanied by Mr Cranz.

A Percydale scholar, T. McMahon, gave a recitation "The Chameleon" in good style.

The candidates for the Spelling Bee of the 4th class then came to the fore and mustered well. The prizes thus fell:—First, William Rutter, Homebush school, quite a little fellow, who took the 3rd prize in the next contest, and who won the special prize for the 3rd class at the competitive examination; second, Margaret McMahon, Percydale school; third, Josephine Cartwright, Lamplough school.

Piano quartette Herold's "Zampa," particularly well rendered by Miss Hall and Mr Cranz, Miss Mather and Mr Armstrong.

Song, Miss Hammond, "Oh take me to my heart again," very sweetly sung.

Chorus and March, Avoca scholars. This was particularly well given, the arrangement being by Mr Cranz. The verses commenced with the old gamut-syllables "do, re, mi, fa, &c.," merging into a march tune, the young executants at the conclusion marching in file from the platform to the entrance vestibule behind, concluding with a dying cadence of the scale. The effect was very good and was much applauded.

Then came the Spelling Bee for the 5th class, for which there was a sturdy competition before the rank was thinned. At last after sustaining the battery of words for some time the prizes were awarded:—First, Hannah Chapman, Bung Bong school; second, Priscilla Cartwright, Lamplough school; third, William Rutter, Homebush school.

Recitation, Albert Wiltshire.

The sixth class Spelling Bee brought out 11 competitors, resulting in W. McMahon (the winner of the special prize), Percydale school, taking the first prize; Martha Rutter, Homebush school, the second; and George Chambers, of Avoca school, the third prize. It was a close contest.

The prizes (value £30) were then distributed as obtained in the late competitive examination, and were in the following order:—

Class VI.—Special prize, William McMahon, Percydale.

Boys—1st prize, William John Williamson, Avoca Lead; 2nd prize, Thomas Quayle, Amphitheatre; 3rd prize, William Loo Ching, Percydale.

Girls—1st prize, Martha Rutter, Homebush; 2nd prize, Emily Birkenshaw, Bung Bong; 3rd prize, Lillie Sutherland, Bung Bong.

Certificates—Edward Bird, Amphitheatre; Albert Scott, Amphitheatre.

Class V.—Special prize, Thomas Sutters, Mountain Hut.

Boys—1st prize, James Hughes, Mountain Hut; 2nd prize, Thomas Green, Lillicur; 3rd prize, John Schmidt, Mountain Hut.

Girls—1st prize, Hannah Chapman, Bung Bong; 2nd prize, Mary Eliza Clark, Lillicur; 3rd prize, Priscilla Cartwright, Lamplough.

Certificates—Joseph Nicholson, Bung Bong; P. P. Moss, Avoca.

Class IV.—Special prize, Thomas Abbott, Bung Bong.

Boys—1st prize, William Mathers, Avoca; 2nd prize, Frederick Frey, Avoca; 3rd prize, Edwin Miles, Avoca.

Girls—1st prize, Emma Rutter, Bung Bong; 2nd prize, Margaret McMahon, Percydale; 3rd prize, Anastasia Brennan, Avoca.

Certificates—William Henderson, Bung Bong; Caroline Beata Butt, Lillicur; Albert Webb, Avoca.

Class III.—Special prize, William Rutter, Homebush.

Boys—1st prize, Christopher Abbott, Bung Bong; 2nd prize, Alfred Fry, Avoca; 3rd prize, George Macadam, Avoca.

Girls—1st prize, Lucy Paddon, Mountain Hut; 2nd prize, Flora Frey, Avoca; 3rd prize, Mary Robarts, Bung Bong.

Certificates—George Stevenson, Lillicur.

Votes of thanks were passed to Mr Cranz, ladies and scholars, and to Mr Bolam, Rev. D. O'Donnell, and the chairman and correspondent of the Board of Advice.

Mr Bolam, in responding, expressed the gratification he experienced on being present, and repeated his willingness to preside on future occasions of the kind if invited to do so.

The singing of the National Anthem concluded the very pleasant proceedings, which reached until nearly midnight.

The proceeds of the entertainment, we hear, were £14 14s. 5d., the amount taken at the door.

Music formed a major part of the 1876 prize distribution. Alongside school songs and recitations, local performers presented piano arrangements of fashionable European works, including selections from Ferdinand Hérold’s opera Zampa. Such pieces were widely played in Victorian drawing rooms and concert halls, illustrating how even a country town like Avoca shared in the musical tastes of the wider nineteenth-century world.

Avoca vs Rural Schools: 1875 Examination Insights

In December 1875 the Avoca Mail published the results of the annual competitive examinations for the state schools of the South Riding School District. These examinations, conducted by Inspector Bolam, tested pupils in dictation, arithmetic, grammar and geography, with prizes and certificates awarded to the highest performers in each age group.

Thomas Bolam in 1883

The results provide a comparison of educational achievement across the district. Although Avoca State School entered by far the largest number of pupils, the smaller rural schools performed remarkably well. Bung Bong equalled Avoca’s total of nine prizes despite entering only nine competitors, while the special prizes in every class were won by pupils from outside Avoca. The newspaper regarded this as a disappointing outcome for the town’s principal school and did not hesitate to criticise the performance of its senior classes.

The article below has been transcribed in full because it records not only the prize winners but also the marks they obtained, the number of competitors from each school, and the newspaper’s candid commentary on the results. The children were from Avoca, Avoca Lead, Amphitheatre, Bung Bong, Homebush, Lamplough, Lillicur, Mountain Hut and Percydale.

Avoca Mail, Friday 24 December 1875, page 2


THE STATE SCHOOLS COMPETITIVE EXAMINATIONS.

The results of the above examinations arrived from Mr Inspector Bolam yesterday morning, and we have been furnished with the Inspector's official list through the courtesy of the Board of Advice for the South Riding School District. From the statement of prize-winners which appears below it will be seen that notwithstanding the fact that Avoca has carried off nine out of the 36 prizes offered (counting certificates of merit in the prize-list), the local school comes out of the contest with very barren honors. Avoca competed in each of the four classes, and in each case sent about as many competitors as all the other schools put together. Notwithstanding this, however, the Bung Bong school, which only sent two competitors to three of the classes and three to the other one, carried off nine prizes also (two only being certificates) each child winning a prize. In the competition of the 6th class Avoca, with eight representatives out of a total of seventeen competing, was altogether left out in the cold. In the 5th class, with seventeen scholars against fourteen sent by all the other schools, Avoca managed to carry off a certificate only, but the winner of this may boast that he can show more marks than the winner of the 1st girl's prize in the same class. The members of the 4th class seem to have had better training than their schoolmates of the 5th and 6th, or else they made better effort for the honor of the town. They succeeded in pulling off five out of the ten prizes offered, eleven from Avoca meeting twelve from other schools. In the 3rd class eighteen of Avoca met seventeen from the suburbs, but only succeeded in taking three out of eight prizes, missing also the special and both of the first prizes. The special prizes have all gone to the outside schools, Master William McMahon having won it in the 6th class for Percydale: Master Thomas Sutters, in the 5th class, for Mountain Hut; Master Thomas Abbott, in the 4th class, for Bung Bong, with a special note of praise for "excellent work." having also reached within ten of the full number of marks obtainable; and Master William Rutter, in the 3rd class, for Homebush, with only five short of the total number of marks obtainable. It will also be observed that the boys have carried off the special prizes on this occasion and thus, although accomplished by other schools, retrieved the defeat of last year. We furnish below a table which we have compiled with the view of showing at a glance the number of prizes obtained by each school, with the number of scholars competing:一
SchoolCompetitorsPrizesCertificatesTotal Prizes
Avoca54729
Percydale7303
Amphitheatre3123
Lillicur9224
Bung Bong9729
Mountain Hut6404
Homebush3202
Avoca Lead10101
Lamplough5101
Total10628836
Amphitheatre competed only in the 6th class: Lillicur, Mountain Hut, and Lamplough, in the 3rd, 4th, and 5th; Homebush in the 3rd, 5th, and 6th; while Avoca, Percydale, Bung Bong, and the Avoca Lead competed in all four classes.

We give below the complete list of prize-takers in the order of prizes and classes, with the name of the school which each prize-taker attends, and the total number of marks obtained at the examination. The subjects in which the children were examined were the same in all four classes, viz:-Dictation, Arithmetic, Grammar, and Geography. Only in one case, that of Master Christopher Abbott, of Bung Bong, does it appear that any marks have been given for writing, and in this instance the Inspector makes a note "five marks specially allowed for penmanship." The total number of marks obtainable in the 6th, 5th, and 4th classes was 350, the limit being extended to 400 in the 3rd class.

CLASS VI.— Under 15 years.— Special prize, William McMahon, Percydale, 240. Boys— 1st prize, William John Williamson, Avoca Lead, 237 ; 2nd prize, Thomas Quayle, Amphitheatre, 203 ; 3rd prize, William Loo Ching, Percydale, 181. Girls— 1st prize, Martha Rutter, Homebush, 196 ; 2nd prize, Emily Birkenshaw, Bung Bong, 176 ; 3rd prize, Lillie Sutherland, Bung Bong, 169. Certificates— Edward Bird, Amphitheatre, 170; Albert Scott, Amphitheatre, 165.

CLASS V.— Under 13 years. — Special prize. Thomas Sutters, Mountain Hut, 300. Boys— 1st prize, James Hughes, Mountain Hut, 261 ; 2nd prize. Thomas Geo. Butt, Lillicur, 254 ; 3rd prize, John Schmidt, Mountain Hut, 235. Girls— 1st prize, Hannah Chapman, Bung Bong, 194; 2nd prize, Mary Eliza Clark, Lillicur, 179; 3rd prize, Priscilla Cartwright, Lamplough, 167. Certificates— Joseph Nicholson, Bung Bong, 233; Philip Whalley, Avoca, 216. 

CLASS IV. — Under 11½  years.— Special prize, Thomas Abbott, Bung Bong, 340. Boys— 1st prize, William Mathers, Avoca, 187; 2nd prize, Frederick Frey, Avoca, 180: 3rd prize, Edwin Miles, Avoca, 173. Girls— 1st prize, Emma Miller, Bung Bong, 244; 2nd prize, Margaret McMahon, Percydale, 222; 3rd prize, Anastasia Brennan, Avoca, 162. Certificates— William Henderson, Bung Bong, 156 ;Caroline Beata Butt, Lillicur, 150; Albert Wiltshire, Avoca, 139.

CLASS III.— Under 10½ years.— Special prize, William Rutter, Homebush, 395. Boys— 1st prize, Christopher G. Abbott, Bung Bong, 290; 2nd prize, Alfred Kelley, Avoca, 285; 3rd prize, George Macadam, Avoca, 225. Girls— 1st prize, Lucy Paddon, Mountain Hut, 333; 2nd prize, Flora Frey, Avoca, 215; 3rd prize, Maria Roberts, Bung Bong, 195. Certificate— Oliver Stevenson, Lillicur, 195. 

The statement from which the above is taken, and which shows also the number of marks obtained by the winners in each separate subject, will remain at this office during the next few days for the inspection of parents, teachers, and scholars, or anyone else who may feel interested in the subject. Much surprise, we might even say indignation, has been expressed at the ignominious defeat suffered by the senior classes of the Avoca School, and the results show that not one day too soon has the competitive examination been instituted. It is certain that if our boys are not making the progress they should do it is better to know the worst at once, in order that efforts may be made for improvement. That an improvement may be speedily accomplished at this school is "a consummation devoutly to be wished." 

Conclusion

The achievements of more than one hundred children are recorded and the schools they attended identified.

Although Avoca entered 54 pupils—more than half of all competitors—it won no more prizes than Bung Bong, which entered only nine pupils. This disparity explains the Avoca Mail‘s unusually critical assessment of the town’s school.

Looking back from the twenty-first century, these examination results reveal much more than academic success. They demonstrate that small rural schools with only a handful of pupils could compete successfully against the much larger Avoca School. Schools such as Bung Bong, Mountain Hut, Homebush and Percydale produced outstanding scholars despite their limited enrolments, testifying to the dedication of their teachers and pupils.

Hannah Bowen and the Fight for Fair Recognition at Avoca State School

The establishment of local Boards of Advice under the Education Act 1872 gave communities an important voice in the management of their schools. Although they had no authority to appoint or dismiss teachers, the Boards advised the Education Department on school accommodation, attendance, discipline and local concerns.

The minutes of the South Riding School Board meeting held in Avoca in August 1873 reveal the wide range of issues confronting the new Board. Among the routine business was an extraordinary appeal from assistant teacher Hannah Bowen, who believed she had been unfairly overlooked for promotion despite holding a higher teaching qualification than the colleague appointed above her. Her detailed letter offers a glimpse into the careers of women teachers and the complexities of staffing Victorian schools in the early years of free, compulsory education.

Avoca Mail, Tuesday 2 September 1873, page 2

THE SOUTH RIDING SCHOOL BOARD.

The usual monthly meeting of this Board was held on Friday evening last in the State School room, Avoca. All the members were present, viz. : — Messrs Powell, (Chairman), Kaye, Griffith, Matthews, and Buhlert (Correspondent).

The minutes of the previous meeting were read, and confirmed on the motion of Messrs Griffith and Kaye.

The following letters, received since the date of the last meeting, were then read by the Correspondent : —

1. From the Education Department, enclosing a copy of the form to be used in applying to the Department for books and other school requirements, and also furnishing information as to the conditions on which the same would be granted.

2. From the same, intimating that the Board's request for additional school accommodation had been referred to the District Inspector for report.

3. From the same, stating that lists of children not attending any schools had been prepared at the beginning of the year, and were now in the keeping of the police, and these were the only ones at pre sent available for the use of the Board.

4. From Miss Hannah Bowen, teacher in the Avoca State School No. 4, as follows : —
" To the Chairman, Correspondent, and Members of the Board of Advice for the School District of the South Riding of the Shire of Avoca.
" Gentlemen, — I respectfully entreat your earnest attention to the recent classification by the Hon. the Minister of Public Instruction of the assistant teachers in the Avoca State School, as follows: — Miss Bacon, 1st assistant ; Mr Ware, 2nd assistant ; Miss Bowen, 3rd assistant.
" The position of third assistant thus assigned to me is (independent of the great difference in salary) so injurious and lowering to my professional status as a first-class certificated trained teacher that, in justice to myself, I cannot permanently accept it, ;and have no other resource than to apply for removal to some other school.
"I am the less content to submit to the lower position because the Minister's decision in favour of Miss Bacon has evidently been influenced by mis-statements made to the Minister in her interest, the direct reverse of the actual truth.
" In the copy of the Minister's decision, furnished by the Education Department, the Minister says: — 'No doubt Miss Bowen has the higher classification ; but Miss Bacon is to be considered, in my opinion, as the actual occupant of the position of first assistant, as, he goes on further to say, it appears that she (Miss Bacon) was actually placed by the School Committee in the higher position, in which position she is when the new Act comes into operation.'
"Now, I emphatically deny the truth of this statement, and assert that whoever made this statement to the Minister grossly misrepresented the known facts of the case.
" These are the true facts : — On the 3rd August, 1870, on the recommendation of the then Inspector-General of Schools, Mr R. H. Budd, I was specially engaged to teach the 4th class (the next highest to the head teacher's classes), and also to superintend the older girls' needlework, etc. The duties of the school, on my engagement, were thus apportioned : The head teacher taught the 5th and 6th classes; I taught the 4th class and upper girls' needle work ; Miss Bacon, the second and third classes ; Miss Ritchie, the infants. As to the manner in which I discharged my duties, I beg to refer you to the District School Inspector, Mr Bolam, as a competent and impartial judge. I continued to teach the 4th class and to superintend the elder girls' needlework, etc., until June 3rd, 1872, when a vacancy occurred in the infant department through the marriage of Miss Ritchie. A male assistant was appointed in Miss Ritchie's stead, and it became necessary to make room for him. I then voluntarily gave up the teaching of the 4th class to the new male assistant, and took charge of the infants, still retaining, however, the superintendence of the elder girls in sewing, etc. This superintendence I continued to exercise until March, 1873, two months after the new Education Act came into force. Up to March, 1873, Miss Bacon's position in the school had remained unchanged. When two assistants were employed, Miss Bacon taught the 2nd class and Miss Ritchie the higher classes. When three assistants were employed in 1870, and I was engaged, Miss Bacon taught the 2nd and 3rd classes, and I taught the higher classes.
" In March 1873, owing to the great increase of scholars, it became necessary to remove the infants to another building at some distance from the school, and I then, for convenience sake, and with the head teacher's approval, gave up the superintendence of the elder girls' needlework to Miss Bacon.
" Reference to the records of the school must undoubtedly evidence the fact that Miss Bacon never, held the first position ; that, on the contrary, the first position was always given to the higher certificated teachers ; and that I virtually filled such higher position, having been specially engaged to teach the higher classes.
" Had the statement that has been made to the Minister by some one in Miss Bacon's interest been true, viz., that she 'was actually placed in the higher position by the Local Committee, in which position she is when the new Act came into operation,' the Minister's decision in her favor would have been a just decision, and it would have been a great injustice to have removed her from that position; but as the statement is the reverse of true, I can not but feel that a great injustice has been done to me and that a great wrong has been enacted by the person or persons who have been guilty of making these misrepresentations to the Minister,
" As I fear that injury may arise to my professional status and repute should these misrepresentations remain uncontradicted, I earnestly appeal to you for an investigation into the facts, with the view of showing that my recent classification as third assistant at the Avoca School was not owing to any want of professional capacity, or to any neglect of professional duty.
"I have the honor to be, gentlemen,
"Your most obedient servant,
" Hannah Bowen.
" Avoca, August 20th, 1873."

5. From John McDonald, Richard Baldwin, and William Sutter, residents of Mountain Hut, complaining of the inefficiency of the teacher of the Mountain Hut School, and also charging him with drunkenness, and with inattention to and illtreatment of the children. Also stating that the writers had withdrawn their children from the school on account of the irregularities named, and requesting the Board to hold an inquiry to inves tigate the charges brought against the teacher.

5. From John Porter, teacher of the Avoca Lead School, asking for increased accommodation at his school, and stating that with an average attendance of nearly 50 children he had only two desks of 12 feet each in length, and these of the worst possible description.

In reference to the first letter from the Education Department, it was decided that the head teachers of the various schools should be made acquainted with the information therein contained.

On Miss Bowen's letter coming on for consideration, Mr Buhlert asked Mr Griffith, as a member of the late school committee, if, at any of the committee's meetings, Miss Bacon had been formally placed in the position of first assistant.

Mr Griffith said he did not remember distinctly the proceedings of the committee, and would rather that Mr Buhlert obtained the information from the committee's minutes.

Mr Kaye thought as the appointments at present stood, a great injustice had been done to the holder of the first-class certificate.

Mr Buhlert said that although the Board could not interfere with or alter the appointments made by the Minister of Education, still he thought it quite came within the duties of the Board of Advice, when an appointment had been made threatening to injure the professional status of a teacher, to inquire into the grounds upon which such appointment was based. He had been informed on very good authority that the Inspector, while admitting excellent teaching qualifications on the part of both ladies, had reported in favor of Miss Bowen obtaining the appointment of first assistant on account of her higher-classification. This, of course, was correct, as it could not he expected that young people would spend their time and energy to obtain high class certificates if they received no consideration when obtained. Miss Bacon was first placed in the position, then, on efforts being made by Miss Bowen's friends, and after the report of the Inspector, the positions were reversed, only again to be realtered, and finally Mr Stephen placed Miss Bacon in the position of first assistant on the ground that when he assumed office he found her in that position, placed therein by the late local committee. Miss Bowen only protested that no such appointment had been made by the late committee, and that therefore the Minister had been induced to make the appointment from false statements. Miss Bowen now sought to protect her position and her professional standing with the Department and her fellow teachers from injury. In this, he thought the Board should give its assistance, for, it should not be forgotten that, in addi tion to the pecuniary loss which she would suffer, her classification as third assistant was calculated to seriously injure her prospects in applying at other schools for employment in the position she was entitled to.

The Chairman (Mr Powell), said he quite agreed with the remarks of Mr Buhlert, he believed that the change in the position of the teachers had, in the first place, been brought about on the removal of the younger children from the main school, and he certainly thought that the manner in which Miss Bowen had allowed herself to float out of her position very extraordinary.

Messrs Matthews and Kaye supported the previous speakers, stating their opinion that as Miss Bowen certainly held a first-class certificate she should not be placed under a teacher who held a second-class one.

Mr Matthews then moved " That the letter be held over until next meeting, and that the Correspondent be empowered to ask Mr Snell for the minutes and papers of the late committee bearing upon the subject." Seconded by Mr Kaye and carried.

On the motion of Mr Griffith, it was decided that a special meeting of the Board should be held at Mountain Hut on Friday next, the 5th inst., at three o'clock, for the purpose of investigating the charges brought against the teacher of that school.

Messrs Powell and Matthews brought up their reports of the schools they had been appointed to visit, viz., — those at Avoca Lead, Lamplough, and Lilicur, at all of which the work of education was said to be progressing, with large average attendance of children, and little or no accommodation.

Mr Buhlert submitted the notices he had obtained for the purpose of serving on the parents of children not attending the schools, and on the motion of Mr Powell, it was decided that these notices should be signed at meetings of the Board by the Correspondent, or in his absence, by the Chairman ; that a record should be kept of all parties on whom notices were served ; and that the effect of these notices should be duly reported to the Board by the members serving the same, the particulars of attendance being obtainable from the roll books of the schools.

Mr Matthews said he knew of fourteen children at Avoca Lead who did not attend any school, but he thought is was useless to enforce the compulsory clause, for in its present state the school could not well receive them even if they were sent.

It was finally decided that the compulsory clause of the Act should only be enforced in the localities provided with sufficient school accommodation.

The Board then adjourned until the last Friday in September.

A campaign for justice

Hannah Bowen’s appeal quickly became a matter of public debate. In October 1873 the Avoca Mail argued that the Minister of Public Instruction had been misled into believing that Miss Bacon already occupied the position of first assistant before the Education Act came into force. According to the newspaper, the school’s records showed that Miss Bowen had been specially selected by Inspector-General R. H. Budd in 1870 to teach the senior classes and had effectively served as first assistant for more than three years before being transferred to the infant department because of the school’s growing enrolment.

The Board of Advice investigated the matter and unanimously forwarded a detailed Statement of Facts to the Minister. Compiled by Correspondent William Buhlert from the school’s records, the report reconstructed the staffing history of the Avoca School from 1866 and concluded that the Local Committee had never appointed Miss Bacon as first assistant, nor had it ever proposed such an appointment. District Inspector D. I. Bolam also confirmed that Miss Bowen’s teaching had consistently been of the standard expected of a first-class trained teacher.

Community support continued to grow. In April 1874, 88 of the 90 parents approached signed a memorial to the Minister, representing 456 children, including 266 attending the Avoca State School. They praised Miss Bowen as an exceptionally capable teacher whose work had never attracted complaint and whose influence upon the children had been “most beneficial”. Rather than seeking Miss Bacon’s demotion, the parents asked that Miss Bowen also be granted the status and salary of a first assistant, arguing that it would be unjust to lose such a valued teacher.

The outcome

The campaign appears to have achieved a partial success. Hannah Bowen’s teacher’s record shows that in May 1874 the Education Department restored her salary to the level she had received under the former Board of Education. Inspector Bolam continued to praise her work, describing her as “a first-class teacher of exceptional ability”, “an excellent teacher”, and “a capital teacher of infants”.

Contrary to expectations in 1874, Miss Bowen remained at Avoca for almost three more years. During that time she continued to lead the infant department and also served as honorary organist and choir leader at the Wesleyan Church. In recognition of four years’ voluntary service, the congregation presented her with an inscribed gold watch and praised not only her musical leadership but also her ability, kindness and influence as a teacher.

Miss Bowen finally left Avoca in January 1877, not because of the earlier dispute but because declining enrolments required a reduction in the teaching staff. Reporting her transfer to Mount Egerton, the Avoca Mail described her as “one of the most efficient of the teachers” who had won “the affection and respect of the children and parents”. The newspaper also revealed that she had previously declined a more lucrative appointment at Hamilton rather than leave the Avoca community.

Although Hannah Bowen never regained the title of first assistant at Avoca, the documentary evidence suggests that she ultimately achieved what she had most sought to protect—her professional reputation. The Board of Advice, the overwhelming support of the parents, the repeated endorsements of Inspector Bolam, the restoration of her salary, and the esteem in which she was held by both the church and the wider community all testify to the regard in which she was held. Together they provide a remarkable case study of a nineteenth-century teacher defending her professional standing in the formative years of Victoria’s state education system.

DateEvent
Aug 1873Miss Bowen appeals to the Board of Advice
Oct 1873Avoca Mail supports her claim
Nov 1873Board forwards Statement of Facts to the Minister
Apr 1874Parents’ petition signed by 88 of 90 parents
May 1874Salary restored
Jan 1877Transfers to Mount Egerton
Public Record Office Victoria VPRS 13579/P0001, Teacher Record No. 373

Related posts

Wikitree

Avoca’s School Boards of Advice

Victoria’s School Boards of Advice were established under the Education Act 1872, which created Australia’s first free, secular, and compulsory public education system. Elected by local ratepayers, these boards acted as the community bridge to the newly formed Education Department, managing local school infrastructure, monitoring attendance, and resolving community grievances. 

Each board consisted of five to seven unpaid members who served three-year terms. They were elected directly by local ratepayers or appointed by the Governor-in-Council.

The board was responsible for:

  • Determination of what use should be made of buildings outside of school hours
  • Suspension of a teacher for misconduct and notification of such decisions to the Minister
  • Report on condition of school buildings and request furniture and other necessities
  • Visit the school from time to time, and report on attendance and give an opinion on management and general condition of the school
  • Encourage regular attendance of children and report on recalcitrant families
  • To recommend school fees and nominate outstanding students for scholarship purposes

Boards of advice were abolished by the Education Act 1910 and replaced with School Committees, which were elected by the parents of students rather than general ratepayers.

Difficulties were anticipated about representation in the North Riding of the Shire of Avoca at the beginning.

Avoca Mail, Friday 23 May 1873, page 3

OPEN COLUMN.
(To the Editor of the Avoca Mail.)
SIR.-- As announced in the public papers, the election of School Boards of Advice must take place in this Shire within one month. This, then, being the right time, I should like to say a few things about the matter through the medium or your widely circulated paper. Seeing that each candidate has to be elected, not by the vote of his own locality, but by the aggregate vote of the whole riding, I fear that, unless considerable judgment and foresight are exercised, that some of the schools in outlying and sparsely populated portions of the district will suffer great loss by not having a local representative on the Board. It must be very desirable that each locality as far as practicable should be represented, and that no one place should have more than its fair share of representation. I should like if possible to have only the required number of candidates nominated, and thus avoid, what in some ridings may be, the very unfair result of the poll.

Take for instance the North Riding of this Shire as an illustration of the matter. There are six schools in it at present-viz, Homebush, Natte Yallock, Redbank, Moonambel, Kimberley, and Percydale, Now they can only have five repre-sentatives for the six schools, and suppose that three were elected at Moonambel, one at Redbank, and one at Percydale, then it must be patent to all, that the Homebush and Natte Yallock Schools would be greatly injured, inasmuch as they would be almost totally unrepresented on the Board. For where is the man who would travel from Moonambel, Redbank, or Percydale, down to Homebush or Natte Yallock, to inquire into the peculiar necessities of the school there. It is unreasonable to expect it, and those who do must only be disappointed. Now if eight or nine candidates were nominated for the said Riding, one or two of the places would almost to a certainty be left out in the cold. I am perfectly acquainted with each of the places named above, and I think I understand what I am writing about; so I beg to suggest :-(1.) That Homebush, Natte Yallock, Redbank, and Moonambel, should each have one local representative, and that Percydale and Kimberley should have one to represent both. I put the latter two places together in this way not because they are small, but because they are more adjacent to each other than any other two places in the Riding. (2.) That the people in each locality should have a meeting of all the ratepayers in such neighborhood, and by a majority of such meeting decide on their man.

In this matter I hope that all will have common sense enough to sink all private, personal, and denominational interests in the general good. I need hardly say that if any one locality bring forward two or three they thus decrease their own strength in proportion to the number of their candidates, themselves in the same ratio, so that the poll may reject all their men. These principles may apply, and increase the strength of other localities against more to the North Riding than to either the South or West, but they are applicable to all in a lesser or greater degree.

I am, yours, &c.,
FAIR PLAY.

Elections for five persons to form the Board of Advice for the school districts of both the south and north ridings of the shire of Avoca were advertised on 3 June 1873.

The Avoca Mail contained correspondence on the topic and advertisements were placed by various candidates.

Avoca Mail, Friday 6 June 1873, page 2

(To the Editor of the Avoca Mail.)
Sir,— There appears to be an unusual stir about the choice of members of the Board of Advice for educational purposes, and in reference to the schools in this, the South Riding of the Shire of Avoca. This is, perhaps, as it should be, so far as regards the importance of the subject, but I begin to fear the small commotion may drift into that kind of spurious excitement which attends upon elections of another kind, and I would steadfastly counsel the ratepayers, those especially who have families, to look carefully at the qualification of those who will be placed in nomination.

Members of Boards of Advice should be qualified to understand at all events the elementary principles of Education, should at least know how to spell English as well as the school children whose mental interests they are supposed to look after.

There should be no clamour or display of partizanship of a noisy nature. Any such would do harm to the great cause of Education itself which is the primary object to be regarded. Members of the Board should know what should be taught and how to teach it. If they do not and harm ensues, the responsibility rests with those who return them.

I am, Sir, etc.,
A VOTER.
Election Results for the Board of Advice for the South Riding of the Shire of Avoca Avoca Mail 20 June 1873, p. 3

George Powell, Simpson John Richard Matthews, William Buhlert, Henry Kaye, and James Griffith were elected as members of the Board of Advice for the South Riding of the Shire of Avoca

Election Results for the Board of Advice for the North Riding of the Shire of Avoca Avoca Mail 27 June 1873, p. 3

George Pinch, Henry Trood Stockman, Joseph Henry Gawith, Henry Hall,
and Frederick Date, were elected as members of the Board of Advice for the North Riding of the Shire of Avoca.

Initially, Boards of Advice were responsible for enforcing compulsory school attendance, using their local knowledge to encourage families to send their children to school. When this proved ineffective, the Education Act Amendment Act 1876 replaced the system with government-appointed truant officers who investigated absences and prosecuted parents when necessary.

Further reading

How schools are governed. (2026, March 27). Victorian Government :Education and Training. https://www.vic.gov.au/how-schools-are-governed   

Avoca Creek No. 1 school 1471

From Vision and Realisation, A Centenary History of State Education in Victoria, Education Department of Victoria 1973, Vol 2: 1471 AVOCA CREEK No. 1 (page 770) 

On 17th of November 1873 DI Bolam recommended the establishment of a school at No. 1 Avoca Creek (in preference to No. 2) and estimated an a.a.[average attendance]  of 15-20. A site of 5 acres, Parish of Tehrip, County of Kara Kara, NW corner of Allotment 47, was gazetted on 16th of January 1874. On this was built, by G. McDonald for £247 7s 9d, a 24ftx16ft wooden school with shingle roof, and two dwelling rooms and large porch attached. This school dates from 1st of January 1875 although the HT Robert Tilley reported first teaching on 11th of January 1875. The a.a. in 1880 varied from 30-36, but had dropped to 13 in 1885, and 20 enrolled in 1886. The school building had been built off the site, and this was changed in 1889, the area then being almost 5 acres (gazetted 1st of March 1889). From 1st of January 1889 Avoca Creek worked part-time with Avoca Lead. The NE [net enrolment] dropped to 12 in 1894 and SS1471 closed on 31st of December 1894. The building was sold for £15 15s 6d for removal in 1903, and the site revoked on 29th of January 1919.

Age, Saturday 10 July 1937, page 7

Old Victorian Schooldays
No. 1 Creek, Avoca.
TO THE EDITOR OF THE AGE.
Sir, —I have longed to see some mention of the little school at No. 1 Creek (1471) State school, which I attended in the late eighties. It was situated at the foot of the Pyrenees mountains. five miles from Avoca, and has long since disappeared.
My two brothers and I attended there. Mr. Tilley was our teacher, and Mrs. Tilley used to teach the girls sewing and knitting. They had two children attending school, Ada and Bob; also a baby whom I used to wheel out in the perambulator. One day I had baby out, and it started raining. I was running back to the school, when the pram turned over, and, of course, out went the baby. Its little shawl got full of grass seeds. When I got home I was afraid to say that baby had a fall, as Mrs. Tilley was very particular where her children were concerned. However, the grass seeds told the story and didn't I get into trouble.
Mr. Tilley and his family were moved to a school at Wedderburn. I saw a letter from a Wedderburn scholar in "The Age" some weeks back referring very appreciatively to our old school master. Then we had a Mr. Roberts, and another master whose name I have forgotten. Neither stayed long. As the attendance was rapidly diminishing, the days of the male teachers ended.
Then came our first lady teacher, a Miss Mary Brennan, from Avoca, where her family lived. She used to come to school on a piebald pony. We children thought it was fun to see her coming up the road in the mornings. Those attending that I can bring to mind are the Quacks, Reeves, Moodies, Gannons. Gollops, Swain, Gledhills, Lamberts, Lamonts, Gales, Suivannas, Francis, Jefferies, Hopes, Laydens, Baileys, Learsons and Freestones.
How we children looked forward to the yearly picnic. Mrs. Tilley and our mothers used to canvass the district for eggs, butter and cream. Those that did not have the above used to give money. What a picnic-swings and all kinds of games and races! I have a salt cellar which I won in a race, and I am very proud of it every time I see
Does anyone remember how the cakes for the picnic were placed around the ledge in the school? Also "Black Jack's" strawberry garden. He used to give all the children living near him 6d. an hour for picking strawberries in the mornings and evenings during the season. He encouraged us to whistle while at work. We would start off waistling, but when he went away we would have a "party" on his straw-berries.
And Reeve's "Magpie." How the bird used to chase us home from school.-Yours, &c..
S.S.
Collingwood.

Natte Yallock State School no 1347

Natte Yallock began as a rural school in 1862, supported by a local subscription list, with 25 children enrolled. At the time, schools could receive government assistance only if they could guarantee an average attendance of at least 20 pupils—a difficult requirement for small, scattered communities.

In 1868 the Board of Education introduced a scheme to assist rural districts by paying teachers’ salaries. Local communities, however, were still responsible for providing the school building and its furniture.

The passing of the Education Act 1872 transformed schooling in Victoria. Education became free, compulsory and secular for children, and state schools replaced the earlier arrangements, providing a more secure basis for education in rural districts such as Natte Yallock.

Weekly Times (Melbourne, Vic.), Saturday 15 September 1934, page 28

Early Days in the Natte Yallock District

Educational Matters
The education of the children of the early pioneers must have caused their parents some concern, for in 1862 a subscription list was opened to raise funds for the erection of a school. This was built from slabs, and on October 21, 1862, it was opened by the late Mr. Jones, with 25 pupils on the roll. They included, Charlotte and Elizabeth Fenton, John, Louisa and Archibald Gardiner, Neil and Norman McPhee, Samuel, Mary and William Plant, Ann and Henry Rickards, Eliza, George and Joseph Ivory, Emalin Wawn, James Jones, John, Ellen and Joseph Coates, Thomas Marshall, Agnes and John Niven and James Henderson. These names were taken from a day book still in the possession of Mr J. Jones, of "Woodlands," a son of the original teacher. Much interesting information concerning the district was compiled in 1923 by Mr. J. J. Hurley, and this has been revised and added to by Mr. Alfred Oppy, the present head teacher of the Natte Yallock school. I am indebted to him for practically all the information contained in this article.

From Vision and Realisation, A Centenary History of State Education in Victoria, Education Department of Victoria 1973, Vol 2: 1347 Natte Yallock (page 762)   

In 1862 a subscription list was opened to raise funds for a school. This was built of slabs on the E side of the Avoca River, and on 21st of October opened by the late Mr Jones. The fee was 4d per day. On 16th of May 1874 tenders were called to build a new school, but were all too high. As the old Common School was not weather proof the Department leased the old Wesleyan Chapel. The present school building was completed ready for use in 1878. Messrs Jones, Todd, Skinner, Mrs Taylor, and Messrs Merchant and Gilsenan taught in the old school. HT Faley taught in the old church and opened the present school. In 1947 the school ground was enlarged to take in the road on the S side. An increase in enrolment resulted in the building of an additional room in 1961. Attempts to establish a pine plantation at the site of the old Moyreisk South School began in 1962.

1882: The first prize day 

Avoca Mail, Friday 1 September 1882, page 2

NATTE YALLOCK STATE SCHOOL.
Friday last was the day appointed for distributing the prizes at the above school, but on account of Mr Paten, who by request was to give away the prizes, being unavoidably absent, it was postponed until last Wednesday. About 21 of the youngsters were all mustered in the schoolroom, and looked jolly and happy. Several visitors were present. After the children were seated, Mr Paten, in addressing them, said that he was sorry that they had been deprived of their worthily-earned prizes for nearly a week. The cause of his not being able to keep his promise was that on the day previous to the Friday a telegram reached Avoca informing him that Mr Thompson and Mr Morgan, two gentlemen largely interested in mining, were coming to Avoca for the purpose of visiting the mines, and so he and Mr Pinch had to show them round. The disappointment was no doubt great, but they had the consolation of knowing that if they had received the books last Friday, they would not have the pleasure of taking them now, and throughout his life he had invariably found that the anticipation of a pleasure was far greater than its realisation. Their teacher, Miss Taylor, deserved the thanks of the parents of every child attending the school, for instituting this, the first Prize Day, and for the trouble she must have taken to raise sufficient funds to purchase the handsome books they saw before them, and which they were shortly to receive, and he was quite sure she deserved the love of every scholar, for it plainly and undeniably showed that she had their future welfare at heart. A great deal depended on the teacher and her power of imparting to them knowledge she possessed; at the same time more depended on themselves, for unless they learned their lessons and were obedient to their teachers they could not possibly advance. He was sorry that the Australian youth, though sharp and quick, were not fond of reading. They preferred shooting, coursing, football, and other sports. These were all very well in their places, but they should not interfere with learning lessons or reading instructive books. History was not unfortunately taught in State schools; this he thought was a great mistake, for he considered history was a most important part of a boy's education, and he hoped the time was not far distant when it would be taught in every school in the colony. He would not keep them any longer, but proceed to distribute the prizes. After the prizes had been awarded Mr Paten urged those who had been successful to go on persevering, and not to flag. They should say to themselves "I have done well this year, but I'll do better next." And to those that had been unsuccessful, he would say, "Do not be disheartened, but make up your mind and win." Remember that "In the bright lexicon of youth there's no such word as fail." He would now ask them to stand up and give three hearty cheers for their teacher, Miss Taylor. This was done with three times three and three more. One of the boys then called for three cheers for Mr Paten, which was heartily responded to.

Ballarat Star, Saturday 9 February 1918, page 2

AVOCA.
HEAD TEACHER'S PROMOTION.
Mr Voce, head teacher of the Natte Yallock State School, has been promoted and transferred to Tarwin Meadows. During his sojourn at Natte Yallock Mr Voce proved a splendid worker and the Patriotic Fund was increased from £5 to £175. The pupils have done remarkably well in their examinations, and Mr. Lowry, the inspector, has furnished a flattering report concerning the school. At present Mr G. Pedlow, late teacher at the Ballarat College, is relieving at Natte Yallock.

Scholars at the Natte Yallock State School
1934: Scholars at the Natte Yallock State School
Moonambel, Redbank and Natte Yallock in the Avoca District (1934, September 22). Weekly Times (Melbourne, Vic.), p. 36

In 2024 Natte Yallock Primary School celebrated its 150th anniversary. That year it was also Victoria’s smallest school.

Further reading

Truancy in the Avoca district

Victoria became one of the first places globally to offer free, secular, and compulsory education via the Education Act 1872. Children aged 6 to 15 were required to attend school for at least 60 days per half-year. 

The definition of reasonable excuse included that the child was under efficient instruction in some other manner; that the child had been educated to the required standard; that the child was prevented from attending school by illness, fear of infection, temporary or permanent infirmity or unavoidable cause or that there was no State school within two miles of the child’s residence. “Reasonable excuses” for missing school included being needed for seasonal farm labor. 

Parents who failed to send their children to school faced fines or imprisonment. By the 1880s and 1890s, dedicated state officers were employed to hunt down truant youths and enforce attendance.

Avoca Mail, Friday 5 July 1878, page 2 

The following circular has been issued by the Education department to truant inspectors : — " Sir, — I have the honour to inform you that in the performance of your duties as truant officer, you should pay especial attention to the detection of any children in your district who may not be in attendance at any school. With this object in view, whenever you find children playing in the streets during the school hours, you will endeavour, by inquiries of the children themselves, of the neighbours, and (if possible) of the police, to ascertain the names and residences of such children ; and the information thus obtained you will follow up until you shall have satisfied yourself as to the extent of their truancy. As often as you have occasion to visit a school, you will request the head teacher to furnish you with particulars of any children who are supposed not to be attending any school ; and similar information should also [be] sought, whenever opportunity offers, from members of boards of advice, and from the police. You will, after instituting the necessary investigation with all such cases, made a special return of those in which persistent truancy is considered to be established, with a view to authority being given for their prosecution."

Avoca Mail, Tuesday 15 March 1881, page 2

AVOCA POLICE COURT.
Monday, March 14th, 1881. (Before C. W. Carr, Esq., P.M., and Wm. Goodshaw, Esq., J.P.)

The undermentioned persons were summoned for a breach of the Education Act in not sending their children to school the required 30 days during the quarter ended the 31st December, 1880 : — John Leyden, Number Two Creek, fined 5s ; Robt. Cockburn, Avoca Lead, fined 5s ; James French, Lamplough, fined 2s 6d ; Patrick Conroy, Upper Homebush, two cases, fined 2s 6d in each case; Frederick Taylor, Upper Homebush, fined 5s ; Meredith Kerr, Upper Homebush, fined 5s ; William Hamilton, Upper Homebush, fined 1s ; Joseph Saunders, Rathscar West, fined 2s 6d ; Chas. Brown, Rathscar West, fined 1s ; Henry Leerson, Number Two Creek, three cases, fined 1s in each case.

Avoca Mail, Tuesday 29 July 1890, page 2

AVOCA COURT OF PETTY SESSIONS.
MONDAY, JULY 28TH, 1890.
(Before Messrs Snell, Wise, and Goodshaw, J's.P.)
TRUANCY.
J. T. Seymour, Truant Inspector, v. Jas. Spencer. Neglecting to send his child to school the requisite number of days, Fined 5s.
Same v. Thomrs Boyd. Similar offence. Two charges. Fined 5s in each.
Same v. Henry Humphreys. Similar offence. Fined 5s.
Same v. Thomas Impey. Similar offence. Fined 5s.
Same v. Mary Ah Pew. Similar offence. Fined 7s 6d.
Same. William Buck.Similar offence. Fined 5s.
Samev Edward Randall. Similar offence. Two charges. Fined 5s in each case.
Samev. Thomas Rowland. Similar offence. Fined 10s.
Same v. James Garner, Similar offence. Fined 10s.
Same. Frederick Whitely. Similar offence. Fined 10s.

Truant officer: James Tudor Seymour (1840-1909)

Parents:

A truant apprehended
Image generated by AI

Further reading

Dee, P. (2022, June 11). Sufficiently educated. State Library Victoria – Blogs: Social, Life & Customs, Such Was Life. https://blogs.slv.vic.gov.au/such-was-life/sufficiently-educated/  

Living memorials: Arbor Day at Lamplough State School, 1917

On Friday 8 June 1917, the pupils of Lamplough State School marked Arbor Day by creating a lasting memorial to former pupils and teachers serving in the First World War. As the Avoca Mail reported:

A row of alternate sugar-gums and Cootamundra wattles was planted along the front of the school-ground in honor of ex-scholars who have volunteered to serve king and country. Two grevilleas or silky oaks were also planted in honor of two ex-teachers, Messrs Wrigley and Looney, who are taking their part in the great war. In every case Australian trees were planted, as these seem the most fitting memorial for Australian soldiers.

“Avoca Mail”, 12 June 1917, p. 2.

More than a century later, the sugar gums planted by the schoolchildren still stand along the former school frontage. They are among the few surviving living memorials to the district’s First World War servicemen and provide a direct link with the Arbor Day ceremony held in 1917.

The soldiers associated with Lamplough at the time of their enlistment included:

The two grevilleas honoured former teachers:

Military records identify four men born at Lamplough who served in the First Australian Imperial Force:

  • Ernest James Young (1878–1942), who enlisted from Melbourne while living at Dandenong.
  • John Frederick Thompson (1882–1947), who enlisted at Kalgoorlie, Western Australia.
  • Charles Herman Burgdorf (1892–1970), who enlisted at Hawthorn.
  • Charles Alexander Gibson (1892–1934), who was still associated with Lamplough when he enlisted.

Today the surviving sugar gums remain a reminder of the schoolchildren’s efforts to honour their former classmates and teachers. Planted during the third year of the war, they continue to commemorate the service and sacrifice of those connected with the small Lamplough community.

Sugar gums Lamplough planted 1917 avenue of honour
Lamplough avenue of honour planted June 1917 photographed June 2026
Wattles are short-lived, and those planted with the avenue of sugar gums are no longer there. It would seem the grevilleas also did not survive.

The teacher at the time was Maurice Barton Isaac (1879-1949) who taught at Lamplough from 1916 to 1918.

Related posts