On 7 May 1885, a twenty-two-year-old miner named John Young was killed by a fall of earth while working in the Golden Stream mine near Avoca. Local newspapers reported the inquest into the accident, and the response of the community. Hundreds of people attended his funeral, subscriptions were raised for his young widow and their child, and the mining company made her a small ex gratia payment.
Avoca Mail, Friday 8 May 1885, page 2
FALL OF EARTH AT THE GOLDEN STREAM CO.'S MINE.
A Miner Buried Alive.
A very sad accident happened at the Golden Stream mine yesterday morning, by which a miner named John Young, 22 years of age, lost his life. It appears that Young, with his mate, Panton, were working in a blocking strip in the No. 3 workings, and the unfortunate fellow was, it is thought, putting in a centre to support the cap piece, and in driving it in he forced the cap piece up, causing it to fall, and he, not being able to escape, was buried under about four tons of earth, which came down without the slightest notice. The laths falling on top of him.
His mate, Panton, had just previous to the accident gone out of the strip to open out another, and was therefore enabled to escape, but had he been in the same strip he would, in all probability, have met with the same fate. The alarm was at once given, and many willing hands amongst whom was the mine manager, Mr. W. Lauder, set to work to release the unfortunate man, who, it was at first thought, might, by some miracle, have escaped death.
After nearly five hours' hard work, the body was reached and it was found that life was extinct. The remains were, as quickly as possible, brought to the surface, where they were examined by Dr. McMahon, who pronounced death to have been caused through suffocation.
The left shoulder was broken, and the body bruised nearly all over. One side of the head and face presented a most frightful spectacle, being completely black and swollen tremendously.
The district coroner, Mr. C. W. Carr, P.M., and the Inspector of Mines, Mr. Trezise, were immediately telegraphed for. The latter arrived by the midday train and paid a visit of inspection to the mine. An inquest will be held this afternoon on the arrival of the coroner, and, if possible, the funeral will take place.
The deceased, who was a member of the Miners' Association, and, it is stated, also had his life insured, was much liked and respected throughout the whole of the district, where he was better known by the name of J. Hope. Much sympathy is felt for his wife, to whom he had only been married about eighteen months. He also leaves a young child.
During yesterday flags were flying at half-mast, and work has been suspended at the mine. Quite a gloom has been thrown over the town by the accident, which is the first of the kind that has occurred at the mine.
The funeral of the deceased took place this afternoon and was very numerously attended. Full particulars will, together with the inquest, appear in our next issue.
Avoca Mail, Tuesday 12 May 1885, page 2
INQUEST ON THE BODY OF JOHN YOUNG
The inquest on the body of John Young, who was killed in the Golden Stream Company's mine by the fall of earth, which occurred on Thursday morning last, was conducted by the Coroner, Mr C. W. Carr, P.M., on Friday afternoon at the Courthouse, Avoca.
The jury sworn in consisted of Messrs. W. J. Moore (foreman), G. Downton, F. H. Gilbert, A. Lake, W. Bosanko, G. Lord, W. Howes, J. Wallis, E. Stowe, S. Purdie, J. McDougall, and H. Butters.
The evidence taken was as follows:—
Alexander Henry Panton
Alexander Henry Panton, miner, residing at Avoca, deposed:—
I knew the deceased, John Young. I was working with him at the Golden Stream on the night shift of Wednesday. We were engaged blocking. After having our crib we came back to where Young was working. We observed the right hand leg of the timber was settling; he called my attention to it. I suggested putting in a centre to support it. He asked the trucker for a leg, and commenced to place it under the cap. I then went into my own face, and started to work.
When I left Young he was sinking a hole to put in the centre. I was working twelve or fourteen feet from him. That is the last I saw of him alive. I heard a rush as of ground coming down a few minutes after I left him. I looked round, as I had my back towards him, and I saw the strip he was working in had all fallen in and covered him. I called him, but received no answer. I told someone to go and look for the boss of the shift.
While he went I went to the next strip to see if I could see any opening and if I could see anything of the deceased, but could not. There were several tons of earth down. The ground was quite dry and strong. I have been mining for fifteen or sixteen years. The deceased was a practical miner. I cannot form any idea how the accident occurred. The timber was put up plumb and well. I cannot say whether he was striking the centre up before the accident. I don't think the accident occurred through any fault of the timbering. After we left crib was the first time I saw any defect in the drive.
Richard Kinniburgh
Richard Kinniburgh, miner, deposed:—
I was working in the Golden Stream on the night the deceased, John Young, was killed. I was trucking for him. I saw him just as the ground was cracking. I had handed him a leg that he was going to put under the main set as a centre to strengthen it. After doing that I went out to see if Panton's truck was full, and as I was standing close to Panton I heard the ground crack, saw deceased fall back, and the ground fall over him. I stood and looked at it for a while as I was frightened to move. I cannot say how the accident occurred.
To the jury:—The leg I gave him was about four feet long and I could carry it easily.
By the Coroner:—I was in the strip where Young put the leg in, and I saw him take it out again. I could not see what he was doing after I left him. He sank a hitch for the centre leg, and in doing so made what I took to be a bar. I did not see the leg leaning towards the broken ground; it had only settled a little.
Thomas Elliott
Thomas Elliott, miner, deposed:—
I am a captain of a shift at the Golden Stream. The deceased was blocking on the morning of the accident. I last saw him alive about half-past one that morning; he was then working in his face. I noticed the timber as I went along and it was all safe.
On my asking him how much further he had to go through, he said, "About a set and a half." The ground is very good, and I could see no sign of any log sinking. When I heard that the ground was down I went into the face where he was working, and crawled through a small space but could not see him. I had the ground opened up and found the body about four feet in.
The only way I could account for the accident is that he was driving the set too tight, and caused the cap to fly off.
To the foreman:—Sometimes we allow the men to work separately, when the ground is safe, but when putting up timber it is understood that two men shall work together.
Thomas B. Trezise
Thomas B. Trezise, Inspector of Mines for the Maryborough District, deposed:—
I inspected the place of the accident at half-past one yesterday afternoon. I went up No. 3 jump-up, along the south drive about fifty feet, and along a drive from thence about 250 feet, and came to the crosscut and strips in which Young had been working.
His strip was all down; there were six sets in it, one of them was leaning towards the face, four others were carried backwards towards the drive. I did not see the leg on the cap of the fifth set. There was a small cavity from the last set to the bottom, about six or seven inches.
I put my arm underneath to try and lift the cap, but could not. I was informed by the captain (Farnsworth) that it was carried into the face. While I was inspecting the ground it was surging. I had to spring into the drive twice while examining the strip.
I could not examine the hitching of the legs, owing to the dangerous nature of the ground. I did not see any broken timber about; hence the sets must have rolled or been canted by some other means.
From what I heard I am of opinion that while Young was in the act of putting in the centre he must have unhooked the main set. It seemed to be good ground for working, and the timber quite strong.
The nature of the ground from that just under that particular set was soft, which may account in some measure for the ground settling.
To the foreman:—I heard that the ground was soft from one of the men that Young relieved. One man frequently puts in centres, and I think it is quite safe.
Joseph Lord
Joseph Lord, miner, deposed:—
I was working in the Golden Stream at the time of the accident. I knew the deceased, who relieved me that night. When I left the ground on Wednesday night, about twelve o'clock, the timber was all standing and quiet. The deceased took my place.
The ground is very good to work in. There did not seem to be any weight on the timber when I left. I cannot say how the accident occurred, unless he was driving the set up too tight and sprung the cap.
To the foreman:—I relieved the deceased, and I told the Inspector there was a quartz reef on one side and the ground was soft. We had passed through similar ground below. The cap had a belly in it, and we put that downwards. The log was about four feet six inches long. I have put centres in myself.
Dr John McMahon
John McMahon, legally qualified medical practitioner, residing at Avoca, deposed:—
I examined the body of the deceased on Thursday morning when he was brought to the surface.
The neck and face were quite swollen and black. The outward extremity of the left collar bone was broken, and the right leg just below the knee. There were no other injuries of any consequence.
The cause of death, in my opinion, was suffocation caused by pressure on the throat.
William Lauder
William Lauder, mining manager, deposed:—
I am the manager for the Golden Stream Company at Avoca. I knew the deceased, who was working in the mine last Thursday morning blocking.
The particular place where he was working is very good ground. I saw it on Wednesday morning previous, and it looked quite sure then. The timber was good.
From what I have seen of the ground since the accident I think it occurred through him driving some timber and so moving other faces.
The men were working in separate faces. We allow that in good ground but not in bad. Deceased was a good miner and knew his work well.
To the Coroner:—It is not customary to use dogs in blocking ground. The sets are spread when there is any danger.
The jury brought in the following verdict:—
"That the deceased was accidentally killed while working in the Golden Stream Company's mine on the morning of the 7th inst."
Avoca Mail, Tuesday 12 May 1885, page 3
A SUGGESTION.
To the Editor of the Avoca Mail.
Sir— The sad accident which occurred at the Golden Stream Company' mine last week, resulting in the death of the young man, John Young, who has left a wife and child entirely unprovided for, calls for some assistance at the hands of those charitably disposed.
I would suggest that something be done to raise a sum of money to assist the widow, and, as I hear that the Ladies' Benevolent Society intend celebrating their anniversary shortly, would it not be a kind act on their part, and I think it would meet with the approval of most of the subscribers, to devote the proceeds derived from the celebration, to the most useful purpose of helping the widow and fatherless child.
Of course I only offer this as a suggestion to the ladies. If it is done, I am sure they will find plenty of willing workers to sell the tickets, as well as to assist in the concert. And no doubt, in this case our Councillors would give the Shire Hall free of charge.
Yours &c.,
A SUBSCRIBER.
Avoca Mail, Tuesday 12 May 1885, page 2
The funeral of the late John Young, who was killed whilst working in the Golden Stream mine, on Thursday morning last, took place on Friday afternoon, and was very numerously attended. The cortege, which left the deceased's late residence about half-past four o'clock, was a very long one, and was headed by a body of over two hundred miners, who marched in twos; then came the hearse followed by nearly all of the principal townspeople. Several residents of Homebush and Percydale, at both of which places the deceased was well-known and greatly liked, came to pay the last tribute of respect to their departed friend.
The funeral service was conducted by the Rev. D. S. Lindsay, who, after having administered the last rite of the dead, delivered one of the most impressive and eloquent addresses we have heard at the grave side, in which he besought all present to prepare themselves for the future world. A hymn was then sung by those present, and an earnest prayer offered up by the rev. gentleman brought the melancholy proceedings to a close.
We regret to state that the rumour current to the effect that the deceased's life was insured, is not true.
Avoca Mail, Friday 29 May 1885, page 2
Complaints are again being brought under our notice of the removal of jars and flowers from the graves of persons whose remains are interred in the local cemetery. These acts cannot be termed anything but mean and contemptible thefts.
The latest report which has reached us, and we can say on very reliable authority, is, that a jug, which had been placed at the head of the grave of the late John Young, who, it will be remembered met with his death in the Golden Stream mine, and which contained some flowers, had been stolen, and a tin substituted for it.
The fact of the tin being put there shows that the act must have been premeditated, and the person must have gone with the intention of stealing the jug. When these thefts are carried to such an extent as this, we think it is high time that the trustees took very stringent measures to have the offenders arrested and severely punished.
As it is now, people are almost afraid to place anything on the graves, expecting when they again visit the cemetery to find it stolen.
Avoca Mail, Friday 5 June 1885, page 2
A meeting of the Avoca Ladies' Benevolent Society was held on Thursday afternoon. After the usual business had been disposed of the letter from "A Subscriber" in the Mail of the 12th May, was discussed and as the Committee were informed that about £100 had been collected for the widow and child of the late John Young, it was decided that the Society need take no action in the matter.
The Avoca Mail, Tuesday 21 July 1885, page 2 contained a report of an ordinary general meeting of the Golden Stream Company. In the meeting it was noted:
Your directors regret to state that during the half-year a fatal accident occurred in your mine, by which a highly esteemed young workman, John Young, lost his life. At the inquest your company was entirely exonerated, but your directors voted a gratuity of £50 to his widow.

The Golden Stream Company worked from 1881 to 1889
Wikitree
- John Walter Young (abt.1862-1885) killed
- Phoebe Margaret (Calaby) Fitch (1864-1933) his wife; she remarried
- Margaret Jane (Young) Mann (1884-1962) John and Pheobe’s infant daughter
- Alexander Henry Panton (1851-1911) miner
- Richard Kinniburgh (abt.1865-1930) miner (brother in law of Alexander Panton)
- Charles Warburton Carr (abt.1824-1888) Coroner
- Thomas Bolitho Trezise (1838-1923) Inspector of Mines for the Maryborough District
- John MacMahon (1824-1892) doctor


































